Transformer winding configurations play a critical role in how voltage is delivered and managed. The two most common winding options are Delta (Δ) and Wye (Y) connections. Understanding these configurations is essential to selecting the right transformer for your project.
Delta vs. Wye: What’s the Difference?
Three-phase transformer coils are made up of three individual coils. How these three single coils connect determines if the winding forms a Delta or Wye.
Wye (Y) Connection
In a Wye configuration, one end of each coil is tied to a common point (or neutral). It’s easy to see how this connection looks like the letter “Y”.
The Wye connection provides both line-to-line and line-to-neutral voltages. This makes it versatile for mixed three-phase and single-phase loads. The neutral point is often connected directly to earth ground. This offers a balanced voltage reference for each phase and a means for operating breakers and fuses.
Delta (Δ) Connection
In a Delta configuration, the transformer windings connect end-to-end as shown below. The three windings form a triangle, or the Greek letter Delta.
In a Delta, the three single coils do not share a common point of connection (neutral) like the Wye. The absence of a neutral makes grounding the Delta difficult. So, Deltas are most common in ungrounded systems. We’ll talk about some neutral options for Delta windings later in this article.
Common Transformer Configuration Options
Both the primary and secondary windings can be configured in either Delta or Wye. This results in several standard combinations, each suited to specific use cases:
Delta-Wye (Δ-Y)
The primary is Delta, and the secondary is Wye, typically with a grounded neutral.
- Use case: Common for stepping down transmission voltage to usable levels in commercial, industrial and residential distribution.
- Advantages: Provides line-to-neutral loading; isolates primary and secondary circuits to reduce harmonics and improve safety.
- Limitations: More complex to ground and protect due to the phase shift introduced between primary and secondary.
Delta Wye configurations are common in the commercial and industrial space. The secondary Wye winding supplies a neutral for effectively grounding the load. These effectively grounded neutrals allow fuses and breakers to trip and protect circuits. The neutral also provides single-phase power for smaller lighting loads.
The primary Delta winding isolates the secondary Wye from the source feeding the transformer. Isolation transformers use Delta Wye configurations for this reason. The neutral currents on the load side winding get trapped in the Delta. Keeping them isolated from the primary source.
Delta Wye transformers do a good job of handling unbalanced loads also. For single phase loads, it is hard to balance the current in the neutral. Resulting in nuisance tripping (a.k.a. breakers and fuses operating when they shouldn’t). In a Delta Wye transformer, the unbalanced neutral currents circulate in the Delta winding. Rather than crowding out the neutral. For severely unbalanced loads, additional sizing may be required for the Delta winding to prevent overheating.
Delta-Delta (Δ-Δ)
Both primary and secondary windings are connected Delta, without a neutral.
- Use case: Manufacturing plants with heavy three-phase motors. Mission critical facilities requiring continuity of service.
- Advantages: Uninterrupted service during a fault.
- Limitations: No neutral connection for line-to-neutral loads. Ungrounded Delta yields high system overvoltages under fault conditions. Overheating of Delta winding due to unbalanced or excessive loading.
It is rare to see a Delta on the primary and secondary nowadays. This is due to the preference for effectively grounded systems. A Delta winding feeding an electrical system often indicates an older installation. As the requirements for grounded systems became more common, grounded Wye systems quickly replaced the ungrounded Delta.
Still, there are some advantages to a Delta winding on the load side of the transformer. For one, an ungrounded Delta system allows for uninterrupted service to a load during a fault. Mission critical applications still use ungrounded Delta services today for this reason.
A 3-wire Delta service has no neutral available for supplying lighting loads. Rather, a smaller auxiliary transformer would step down the service voltage for powering lights and receptacles.
Wye-Wye (Y-Y)
Both the primary and secondary windings are connected in a Wye, each providing a neutral point.
- Use case: Less common in practice, but sometimes used when both primary and secondary need a neutral.
- Advantages: Both neutrals can be grounded for fault detection and protective relay operation. Ideal in systems where loads are evenly balanced across phases.
- Limitations: Prone to third harmonic distortion and circulating currents if not properly grounded and balanced.
The Wye connection is widely used by utilities. The neutral allows for effective system grounding. This grounding capability enables the system to reduce insulation requirements to roughly 58% of the line-to-line voltage rating. This practice goes back many years. It remains a key consideration when selecting transformers for utility applications. If you've ever wondered why a utility specifies a Wye connection on the primary, this could be why.
Wye Wye is also used for solar projects. The grounded Wye interface works well for utilities, and the lower voltage Wye provides an ideal connection for the inverter. Learn more about solar transformers.
Wye-Delta (Y-Δ)
The primary is Wye, with a Delta secondary.
- Use case: Typically used in step-up transformer applications (generator output to transmission lines). Distribution substations feeding industrial facilities from a grounded utility supply.
- Advantages: Suitable for generators or systems that require grounding on the high voltage side.
- Limitations: No neutral on the low voltage side. Only used for grounding banks and generator step-up applications as a rule.
Wye-Delta transformers serve as both grounding banks and generator step up transformers. They allow for a grounded Wye primary, providing a return path for fault current. While the ungrounded Delta secondary side limits fault current.
Grounding transformers have connections made only to the Y winding. Unless auxiliary loads with different voltages need power, the Delta winding gets no connections. Where there are no auxiliary loads, the Delta connections are internal (not brought out to a bushing).
As a generator step-up transformer, the generation side feeds the lower voltage Delta winding. The Wye neutral provides an effective grounding point for the system requiring power. Typically, the Wye side will bring out 4 bushings. Three for the ungrounded phases. One for the grounded phase or neutral. The neutral bushing can be grounded at the transformer for a single point ground. Or, a neutral conductor may be connected and carried with the other three-phases for multipoint neutral grounding.
Utility Interconnection and Grounding Considerations
Most systems built nowadays are grounded. Fault detection in systems with a grounded neutral is simpler. One reason utilities usually require a grounded Wye. Ensuring safety, fault coordination, and voltage stability. Solidly grounded systems provide a low-impedance path for fault current. This allows protective devices like fuses and breakers to operate properly. They also minimize the risk of overvoltages during transient events (lightning strikes or line switching).
In ungrounded Delta systems, fault detection is more complex. The absence of a neutral point on the winding complicates protection schemes. Since faults can persist undetected, some systems ground one phase of the Delta winding (called a corner-grounded Delta). Other systems add what is known as a lighting tap to the center of one coil. This lighting tap provides a neutral on one coil (known as a high leg Delta system). These grounding alternatives are not ideal for most systems. Learn more about corner-grounded and high leg deltas.
In Delta-Wye transformers, the Delta primary helps isolate utility harmonics. While the Wye secondary provides a grounded neutral for the customer’s load. Coordinating with the utility during transformer replacement or design is essential. Mismatched configurations can cause protection issues, circulating currents, or utility interconnection violations. Let’s look at some of these configuration issues.
How to Choose the Right Configuration When Replacing an Existing Transformer
Should I match the old unit? Can I source something different?
As a rule, you should match the configuration of the transformer you are replacing. The system is designed for a specific transformer and winding configuration. Changing this configuration could cause issues.
But what if an identical unit isn’t readily available. And, you can’t wait for a built to order unit. In failed transformer emergencies it can be tempting to buy a unit that isn’t an exact match. In these situations there are several considerations at play when sourcing a different winding configuration.
Here are the most common scenarios:
My previous transformer had a Delta primary. Can I use a Wye instead?
A lot depends on the source feeding the transformer. Is the power source feeding the old Delta Wye transformer grounded Wye, ungrounded Wye, or ungrounded Delta? A Delta Wye transformer works with any three of those source types. But a different configuration might not. These are the factors you need to consider:
Transformer winding insulation
The winding insulation needs to be insulated for the type of system feeding it. Ungrounded systems require a fully insulated winding. Grounded systems could go either way.
Bushing Connection
You must have bushings available for whatever cables are brought to the transformer from the source. Obviously if you had a Delta primary on the old unit, you would not have a neutral, so a three bushing primary is needed (H1, H2, H3).
A grounded Wye unit will often only bring out 3 primary bushings, and internally ground the H0 to the X0. In this case, the unit would be fed by a grounded Wye source (neutral grounded at the source). No neutral conductor is run to the transformer. Because only three conductors come into the transformer, this is often mistaken for a three wire Delta source. Remember most utilities utilize a grounded system (which is not really possible with a Delta). It could be that the old transformer used a Delta primary to isolate the load from the grounded Wye utility. This would prevent circulating currents between the utility and the customer’s load from causing disturbances and nuisance tripping of protection devices.
If the old system was an ungrounded Delta (or Wye), then the transformer would have to have a fully insulated primary. Read more on that here. Since some utility systems use a Delta feed, you shouldn’t assume everything is grounded Wye from the utility. The only way to know the type of source is to ask the owner of the primary power (whether privately or utility owned). If you cannot determine the type of source, the best option is to wait the longer lead time to replace the old unit with what was there before. Better to wait than gamble with your electrical system.
The utility’s source is Wye, do I need a Wye primary connection at the transformer?
All of the issues we just looked at apply here as well. To answer this question, we have to know whether or not the Wye is grounded or ungrounded. We also need to know the number of cables coming in from the utility.
If you have four cables coming in, three ungrounded phases and a neutral, you need a transformer with 4 bushings (H1, H2, H3, and one neutral H0). That means a Wye. And, if the utility supplies a Wye, it will usually be grounded. You still need to verify with the provider of the source power to be sure. To recap, when the source brings in a four wire system, you really only have one option: a transformer primary Wye with four bushings.
What if the utility supplies a grounded Wye with only three cables? In this situation you have more options. A grounded Wye or Delta may work. A Delta Wye option typically works better for end users. As mentioned earlier, the Delta primary isolates the end user’s load from pesky circulating currents between the utility and the transformer primary resulting from Wye Wye interconnections.
That being said, some utility systems are set up for only grounded Wye primary interconnections. Installing a Delta winding in a grounded Wye system could result in serious problems. So again, you have to check with the utility or power source provider for what is required.
Now let’s take a step back from the source power side and consider winding configuration challenges within an end user’s system.
I have two Delta Wye transformers installed in a main-tie-main. One failed, can I replace the failed one with a Wye Wye?
First, what is a main-tie-main?
A main-tie-main has two transformers connected together by a single bus tie. This provides reliability and continuous power in the event of a fault. Basically, one transformer feeds the load(s) at a time, while the second acts as a spare.
In the event of an issue with the unit under load, a transfer switch moves the load to the other transformer. When this happens, the two transformers operate in parallel for a brief time. And, when paralleled (for however long), they must match each other very closely. The differences between a Delta Wye and Wye Wye would cause a serious and dangerous hazard if you attempted to operate them in parallel. Imagine a car engine with the wrong timing. The cylinders and valves could crash into each other since they are out of sync and destroy the engine. The risks are just as severe with a main-tie-main. Matching both transformers is critical.
In most cases, you should replace transformers in a system with an exact match of the original transformers. Consult with your engineer and local utility before making any changes in transformer winding configuration.
Need help finding a transformer?
Designing a new system or replacing an existing transformer? Give Maddox a call. We stock transformers in all winding configurations at locations across the USA. Fill out the form below to get the right transformer for your project–fast.
